The upcoming LGBTQ-themed teen comedy She’s the He is set to premiere at the South by Southwest (SXSW) Film Festival on March 9, 2025. Written and directed by Siobhan McCarthy, the film is already generating buzz for its fresh take on gender identity and self-discovery.
A Story Rooted in Comedy and Identity
At its core, She’s the He blends humor with an exploration of teenage identity. The story follows Ethan (Misha Osherovich) and Alex (Nico Carney), two best friends who hatch a plan to help Alex attract his crush. Their strategy? Pretend to be trans women. However, this lighthearted experiment takes an unexpected turn when Ethan realizes she is actually trans.
The film delivers comedy while tackling themes of gender identity, friendship, and self-acceptance. A memorable trailer moment features Ethan saying, “The only way that I can think of to make you seem not super gay is if I was a girl.” To which Alex enthusiastically responds, “You’re a genius. We both pretend to be trans.”
A Strong Cast and Debut Director
Marking her feature film debut, Siobhan McCarthy brings a fresh perspective, with storytelling that focuses on identity and social themes. The cast includes an impressive mix of rising stars and familiar faces, including:
- Suzanne Cryer (Broad City)
- Mark Indelicato (Hacks)
- Malia Pyles (Pretty Little Liars: Original Sin)
- Emmett Preciado (Good Trouble)
- Aparna Nancherla (Another Simple Favor)
- Kyle Butenhoff (Monsters)
Osherovich, known for their role in Freaky, offers a nuanced performance as Ethan, portraying the character’s transformation with authenticity. Carney, a comedian recently featured on Late Night With Seth Meyers, adds comedic brilliance to the film.
Festival Buzz and Future Prospects
As She’s the He gears up for its SXSW premiere, the film is actively seeking a distribution deal. The audience’s reaction could determine whether it lands with an indie distributor, moves to a streaming platform, or secures a larger theatrical release.
SXSW has a history of launching breakout indie films, including the critically acclaimed Everything Everywhere All at Once. If She’s the He capitalizes on its festival momentum, it could become a standout in the indie film scene.
Representation and Cultural Impact
Coming at a time of heightened discussions around LGBTQ representation, She’s the He adds to the evolving conversation. While its premise—a story centered on characters initially pretending to be trans—may spark debate, the filmmakers appear committed to telling an authentic journey of self-discovery.
Some may praise its thought-provoking approach, while others might critique its sensitivity. The ultimate question is whether the film deepens LGBTQ narratives or inadvertently reinforces stereotypes.
A Comedy That Challenges Norms
As LGBTQ stories expand on screen, She’s the He delivers a unique blend of comedy and emotional depth. It’s about more than just deception—it’s a film about discovering oneself in unpredictable ways.
With its SXSW debut approaching, the response will determine if it becomes a breakout indie hit or generates controversy. Either way, She’s the He is sparking conversations and bringing humor to an important narrative.
For those eager to watch the film, keep an eye out for distribution updates in the coming weeks. Read more about it here.